Judge overturns 1995 homicide convictions, orders new trial - KULR8.com | News, Weather & Sports in Billings, Montana

Judge overturns 1995 homicide convictions, orders new trial

Posted: Updated:
David Wayne Nelson David Wayne Nelson

By AMY BETH HANSON
Associated Press

HELENA, Mont. (AP) - A Montana judge has vacated the deliberate homicide convictions of two men in the 1995 death of a Helena woman and ordered new trials.

District Judge Kathy Seeley ruled Friday that DNA evidence that connects convicted murderer David Nelson to the killing of Donna Meagher far exceeds the standard of a "reasonable probability of a different outcome at trial."

She heard arguments on March 9 on motions filed by the Montana Innocence Project on behalf of Freddie Joe Lawrence and Paul Jenkins.

Innocence project founder and president Dan Weinberg says the he's happy the court "recognized the obvious injustice that occurred in this case" and said the organization would continue to work with the men until they are freed.

The state will now have to decide if it will re-try the men.

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • StatewideMore>>

  • Data breach threatens Bozeman utility customers

    Data breach threatens Bozeman utility customers

    Monday, July 16 2018 8:49 PM EDT2018-07-17 00:49:56 GMT

    A data breach could've targeted thousands of Bozeman residents who paid utility bills through the city's Click2Gov system.

    A data breach could've targeted thousands of Bozeman residents who paid utility bills through the city's Click2Gov system.

  • Accident blocks Northbound Reserve Street in Missoula

    Accident blocks Northbound Reserve Street in Missoula

    Monday, July 16 2018 7:42 PM EDT2018-07-16 23:42:00 GMT
    Both northbound lanes of Reserve Street are blocked near the Travelers Inn Motel in Missoula after an accident. We have a reporter headed to the scene and will provide updates as they are available.
    Both northbound lanes of Reserve Street are blocked near the Travelers Inn Motel in Missoula after an accident. We have a reporter headed to the scene and will provide updates as they are available.
  • L.A., San Francisco, Portland: Bozeman Airport adds daily, nonstop flights

    L.A., San Francisco, Portland: Bozeman Airport adds daily, nonstop flights

    Monday, July 16 2018 7:07 PM EDT2018-07-16 23:07:02 GMT

    BELGRADE - Bozeman Yellowstone International Airport continues its growth with the announcement of flights from Bozeman to three new daily, year-round destinations. United Airlines recently announced it has added daily, non-stop flights to its California hubs in Los Angeles and San Francisco.

    BELGRADE - Bozeman Yellowstone International Airport continues its growth with the announcement of flights from Bozeman to three new daily, year-round destinations. United Airlines recently announced it has added daily, non-stop flights to its California hubs in Los Angeles and San Francisco.

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • 12-year-old girl missing in Kalispell

    12-year-old girl missing in Kalispell

    Friday, July 13 2018 6:28 PM EDT2018-07-13 22:28:03 GMT

    KALISPELL - Police are asking for help finding a 12-year-old girl who hasn't been seen since July 6. 

    KALISPELL - Police are asking for help finding a 12-year-old girl who hasn't been seen since July 6. 

  • Video goes viral about Bozeman man's flag

    Video goes viral about Bozeman man's flag

    Friday, July 13 2018 6:49 PM EDT2018-07-13 22:49:39 GMT

    A Bozeman man says he came home on Tuesday and found a note on his door asking him to take down his American flag. 

    A Bozeman man says he came home on Tuesday and found a note on his door asking him to take down his American flag. 

  • Drunk driver crashes going 100 MPH on I-15

    Drunk driver crashes going 100 MPH on I-15

    Monday, July 16 2018 11:49 AM EDT2018-07-16 15:49:30 GMT

     Witnesses say the driver was traveling over 100 MPH and tried to light a cigarette, causing her car to go over the median and roll over.

     Witnesses say the driver was traveling over 100 MPH and tried to light a cigarette, causing her car to go over the median and roll over.

  • One dead after rollover crash outside Missoula

    One dead after rollover crash outside Missoula

    Monday, July 16 2018 11:02 AM EDT2018-07-16 15:02:36 GMT

    A 45-year-old man is dead after a rollover crash outside Missoula Sunday evening.

    A 45-year-old man is dead after a rollover crash outside Missoula Sunday evening.

  • Plentywood gets smacked with 2 storms in 90 minutes; Majority of town sees damage

    Plentywood gets smacked with 2 storms in 90 minutes; Majority of town sees damage

    Wednesday, July 11 2018 1:00 PM EDT2018-07-11 17:00:11 GMT

    PLENTYWOOD - A massive storm in northeastern Montana has caused serious damage to the town of Plentywood.  Taylor Ordahl, a local photographer, told us the storm hit hard for about 15 minutes before rearing it's ugly head again another 45 minutes later. "We could see it building as we were driving into town. It started pouring as we pulled into our driveway.  We watched everything happen from our bay window in our kitchen.", said Ordahl After the first storm hit ...

    PLENTYWOOD - A massive storm in northeastern Montana has caused serious damage to the town of Plentywood.  Taylor Ordahl, a local photographer, told us the storm hit hard for about 15 minutes before rearing it's ugly head again another 45 minutes later. "We could see it building as we were driving into town. It started pouring as we pulled into our driveway.  We watched everything happen from our bay window in our kitchen.", said Ordahl After the first storm hit ...

  • Name released of motorcyclist who died near Lolo on Friday

    Name released of motorcyclist who died near Lolo on Friday

    Monday, July 16 2018 1:44 PM EDT2018-07-16 17:44:27 GMT

    MISSOULA - The county sheriff's office released the name of a 20-year-old man who died in a motorcycle wreck on July 13. 

    MISSOULA - The county sheriff's office released the name of a 20-year-old man who died in a motorcycle wreck on July 13. 

  • More details released in fatal rollover near Missoula on Sunday

    More details released in fatal rollover near Missoula on Sunday

    Monday, July 16 2018 5:22 PM EDT2018-07-16 21:22:11 GMT
    Photo: Missoula Rural Fire DistrictPhoto: Missoula Rural Fire District
    Photo: Missoula Rural Fire DistrictPhoto: Missoula Rural Fire District

    MISSOULA - Investigators say a driver trying to pass on a one-lane road died after rolling his car on Sunday evening.

    MISSOULA - Investigators say a driver trying to pass on a one-lane road died after rolling his car on Sunday evening.

  • Finally, indisputable proof: Bigfoot spotted in northern California

    Finally, indisputable proof: Bigfoot spotted in northern California

    Saturday, January 10 2015 4:33 PM EST2015-01-10 21:33:06 GMT
    ROSEVILLE, Cali.- There is new, indisputable proof that Bigfoot exists, and has been spending most of his time in northern California. The footage was sent to a Paranormal group by a photographer/videographer who specializes in aerial videography using a quadcopter. A quadcopter is a drone that is lifted and propelled by 4 rotors.
    ROSEVILLE, Cali.- There is new, indisputable proof that Bigfoot exists, and has been spending most of his time in northern California. The footage was sent to a Paranormal group by a photographer/videographer who specializes in aerial videography using a quadcopter. A quadcopter is a drone that is lifted and propelled by 4 rotors.