"Licensed Healthcare Professional" banned from courtroom - KULR8.com | News, Weather & Sports in Billings, Montana

"Licensed Healthcare Professional" banned from courtroom

Posted: Updated:

It's day four in the trial of a Belt football player, suing Benefis for negligence after a devastating injury in 2014 left him a quadriplegic. 

Thursday morning in the courtroom, those in attendance saw two major themes happening even before lunchtime: credibility of evidence and experts, and use of the term "licensed healthcare professional."

University of Colorado neuroradiologist, Dr. David Rubenstein, took the stand to explain a handful of Robert Back's CT scans.  

He tried to discredit an illustration made by Benefis, showing Robert's brain from a vertical point of view... something Rubenstein says is impossible to do with a CT scan. 

But Benefis attorneys had a quick response, highlighting Rubenstein's qualifications and lack of experience in the surgery room. 

Rubenstein was just one of many witnesses to spark tension between the attorneys .

J.C. Weida is Head Athletic Trainer at the University of Montana. He repeatedly referred to himself, and the athletic trainer involved in the suit, Jessica Hansen, as 'licensed healthcare professionals," which is a term that's still being debated by attorneys and could help determine whether or not Hansen can be held legally responsible in Robert Back's injury. 

Until Judge Kutzman makes a decision on what exactly that term means and whether or not Jessica Hansen falls under it, he has banned the phrase from being used in the courtroom by the attorneys or the witnesses. The trial is scheduled to continue to Friday. 

  • Most Popular

  • Regional NewsMore>>

  • Delta bans pit bulls as service dogs due to safety concerns

    Delta bans pit bulls as service dogs due to safety concerns

    Friday, June 22 2018 8:55 AM EDT2018-06-22 12:55:46 GMT

    ATLANTA - Delta Air Lines says it's no longer allowing passengers to fly with "pit bull type" dogs as service or support animals.    The Atlanta-based airline describes its ban announced this week as an "enhancement" to its policy on animals in passenger areas. Delta also says it's limiting travelers to a single emotional support animal per flight. The changes take effect July 10. 

    ATLANTA - Delta Air Lines says it's no longer allowing passengers to fly with "pit bull type" dogs as service or support animals.    The Atlanta-based airline describes its ban announced this week as an "enhancement" to its policy on animals in passenger areas. Delta also says it's limiting travelers to a single emotional support animal per flight. The changes take effect July 10. 

  • Inquest finds officers justified in killing Montana man

    Inquest finds officers justified in killing Montana man

    Thursday, June 21 2018 4:11 PM EDT2018-06-21 20:11:27 GMT

    BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) - An inquest has found officers were justified in shooting and killing a Montana man who was high on methamphetamine and had barricaded himself inside a sporting goods store with a cache of weapons and shot at officers.    Jurors said Thursday there was no criminal conduct on behalf of the Billings police officers who shot and killed Frank Joey Half, Jr. last November.

    BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) - An inquest has found officers were justified in shooting and killing a Montana man who was high on methamphetamine and had barricaded himself inside a sporting goods store with a cache of weapons and shot at officers.    Jurors said Thursday there was no criminal conduct on behalf of the Billings police officers who shot and killed Frank Joey Half, Jr. last November.

  • Kennewick man comes home to find coyote in kitchen

    Kennewick man comes home to find coyote in kitchen

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 8:21 AM EDT2018-06-20 12:21:37 GMT

    KENNEWICK, Wash. - A Kennewick man got quite the shock Monday night after finding a startled coyote pup cowering in his home. Jake McChesney was just getting home from work when his dog started barking at something in the kitchen. Jake says he had left his back door open so that his dog could get in and out of the house and believes that's how the coyote got inside. 

    KENNEWICK, Wash. - A Kennewick man got quite the shock Monday night after finding a startled coyote pup cowering in his home. Jake McChesney was just getting home from work when his dog started barking at something in the kitchen. Jake says he had left his back door open so that his dog could get in and out of the house and believes that's how the coyote got inside. 

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Two injured in Montana after swerving to avoid a kangaroo or wallaby

    Two injured in Montana after swerving to avoid a kangaroo or wallaby

    Thursday, June 21 2018 7:02 PM EDT2018-06-21 23:02:48 GMT
    kangaroo (Wikimedia Commons)kangaroo (Wikimedia Commons)

    UPDATE: Sources now indicate that the animal may actually have been an escaped wallaby from a petting zoo on the Fort Belknap Reservation.

    UPDATE: Sources now indicate that the animal may actually have been an escaped wallaby from a petting zoo on the Fort Belknap Reservation.

  • Man charged with DUI in crash

    Sunday, June 24 2018 1:47 PM EDT2018-06-24 17:47:14 GMT

    62-year-old Glenn Wilkerson is being charged with aggravated DUI, DUI and careless driving Last night right before midnight the Great Falls Police Department responded to a crash on the 9th Street bridge. GFPD tell us that it was a 4 car crash in the southbound lanes with a 10-year-old and a 5-year-old in one of the vehicles. There were injuries reported but GFPD does not know the extent of the injuries. GFPD tells us that more charges could come depending on the investigation....

    62-year-old Glenn Wilkerson is being charged with aggravated DUI, DUI and careless driving Last night right before midnight the Great Falls Police Department responded to a crash on the 9th Street bridge. GFPD tell us that it was a 4 car crash in the southbound lanes with a 10-year-old and a 5-year-old in one of the vehicles. There were injuries reported but GFPD does not know the extent of the injuries. GFPD tells us that more charges could come depending on the investigation....

  • Bus contractor charged with child endangerment over meth

    Bus contractor charged with child endangerment over meth

    The owner of a company that has the bus contract for a northwestern Montana school district faces charges for allegedly possessing and selling methamphetamine and smoking it on the school buses and in the bus barn.

    The owner of a company that has the bus contract for a northwestern Montana school district faces charges for allegedly possessing and selling methamphetamine and smoking it on the school buses and in the bus barn.

  • State of Emergency issued for Great Falls, Cascade County, and Lewis & Clark County

    State of Emergency issued for Great Falls, Cascade County, and Lewis & Clark County

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 8:53 PM EDT2018-06-21 00:53:18 GMT

    The National Weather Service has issued a flood warning for Great Falls. The Missouri River is expected to crest at 17 feet, a height that matches the historic crest of 1953, as early as the afternoon on Thursday, June 20th, and is expected to last at least into late Friday, June 21st. If you live on or near Woodland Estates Road and the Country Club area of Great Falls, prepare for flooding now.

    The National Weather Service has issued a flood warning for Great Falls. The Missouri River is expected to crest at 17 feet, a height that matches the historic crest of 1953, as early as the afternoon on Thursday, June 20th, and is expected to last at least into late Friday, June 21st. If you live on or near Woodland Estates Road and the Country Club area of Great Falls, prepare for flooding now.

  • Search organized in Missoula for missing woman

    Search organized in Missoula for missing woman

    Sunday, June 24 2018 6:17 PM EDT2018-06-24 22:17:36 GMT

    A community search has been organized in Missoula in for a woman who has been missing for a week. Jermain Austin Charlo (aka Jermain Morigeau 'Liz') was last seen in Missoula near Orange Street and S. 5th Street early last Sunday morning.

    A community search has been organized in Missoula in for a woman who has been missing for a week. Jermain Austin Charlo (aka Jermain Morigeau 'Liz') was last seen in Missoula near Orange Street and S. 5th Street early last Sunday morning.

  • No charges filed in Lodge Grass triple murder

    No charges filed in Lodge Grass triple murder

    Friday, June 22 2018 6:08 PM EDT2018-06-22 22:08:16 GMT

    After a careful review of the evidence and witness testimony, prosecutors concluded the investigation could not conclusively determine who shot whom, or in what order the shots were fired.  Thus, there is no way to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, who actually fired the shot(s) that killed any of the decedents. 

    After a careful review of the evidence and witness testimony, prosecutors concluded the investigation could not conclusively determine who shot whom, or in what order the shots were fired.  Thus, there is no way to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, who actually fired the shot(s) that killed any of the decedents. 

  • Two in custody allegedly trying to steal boats

    Two in custody allegedly trying to steal boats

    Saturday, June 23 2018 12:48 AM EDT2018-06-23 04:48:55 GMT

    In court Friday two men, Ruben Stump and Thomas Hernandez, made their initial appearance in connection with the same crime of attempted theft and obstructing a police officer. 

    In court Friday two men, Ruben Stump and Thomas Hernandez, made their initial appearance in connection with the same crime of attempted theft and obstructing a police officer. 

  • Crow tribe will pursue charges in triple homicide

    Crow tribe will pursue charges in triple homicide

    Saturday, June 23 2018 5:48 PM EDT2018-06-23 21:48:47 GMT

    BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) — A day after federal prosecutors said they could not prove who was responsible for a triple homicide on the Crow Indian Reservation last August, the tribal chairman said he will do everything in his power to make sure justice was done

    BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) — A day after federal prosecutors said they could not prove who was responsible for a triple homicide on the Crow Indian Reservation last August, the tribal chairman said he will do everything in his power to make sure justice was done

  • NewsMore>>

  • State Officials tour flood damage

    State Officials tour flood damage

    Friday, June 22 2018 3:07 PM EDT2018-06-22 19:07:58 GMT
    Lt. Gov. Mike Cooney speaks to Dorthy OpheimLt. Gov. Mike Cooney speaks to Dorthy Opheim
    Lt. Gov. Mike Cooney speaks to Dorthy OpheimLt. Gov. Mike Cooney speaks to Dorthy Opheim
    Lt. Governor Mike Cooney toured the flooded Sun River community today, June 22nd. Flooding began in the town earlier in the week, washing away roads, flooding homes, and trapping some people inside their town. Lt. Gov. Cooney spoke to several families, including the Opheim's. Right now, it's difficult to say how much money it will cost to repair roads and homes, but officials are working to find an answer.
    Lt. Governor Mike Cooney toured the flooded Sun River community today, June 22nd. Flooding began in the town earlier in the week, washing away roads, flooding homes, and trapping some people inside their town. Lt. Gov. Cooney spoke to several families, including the Opheim's. Right now, it's difficult to say how much money it will cost to repair roads and homes, but officials are working to find an answer.
  • Roads closed as flooding hits Augusta

    Roads closed as flooding hits Augusta

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 10:24 PM EDT2018-06-21 02:24:11 GMT

    AUGUSTA - Flooding is being reported on Main Street in Augusta and along US Highway 287 at mile marker 38. 

    AUGUSTA - Flooding is being reported on Main Street in Augusta and along US Highway 287 at mile marker 38. 

  • Death ruled accidental in Milk River drowning

    Death ruled accidental in Milk River drowning

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 5:53 PM EDT2018-06-20 21:53:29 GMT

    The body of a missing Chinook man has been found. According to Blaine County Sheriff Glen Huestis, the body of Noah Hofeldt was found Sunday evening around 5:30pm by volunteers floating the Milk River searching for Hofeldt.  Sheriff Huestis says they believe Hofeldt went missing as early as Monday, June 11th.  It is still unclear what led to the death, but foul play is not suspected. Hofeldt's body is being sent to Billings Tuesday morning for an autopsy. Until then, Sheri...

    The body of a missing Chinook man has been found. According to Blaine County Sheriff Glen Huestis, the body of Noah Hofeldt was found Sunday evening around 5:30pm by volunteers floating the Milk River searching for Hofeldt.  Sheriff Huestis says they believe Hofeldt went missing as early as Monday, June 11th.  It is still unclear what led to the death, but foul play is not suspected. Hofeldt's body is being sent to Billings Tuesday morning for an autopsy. Until then, Sheri...

  • Update: Woman rescued, 13 people still stranded in Wilderness

    Woman rescued, 13 people still stranded in Wilderness

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 9:07 PM EDT2018-06-20 01:07:43 GMT

    A woman walking near Hauser Dam has been rescued after weather and slippery conditions caused her to get lost.  According to the Lewis and Clark County Sheriff's Office, the woman is safe and uninjured. Her identity has not yet been released. As of 10:30 Monday evening, authorities were taking the woman back to her vehicle.  At the same time, a group of 13 people lost their way in the Bob Marshall Wilderness. Lewis and Clark County Sheriffs say the group got stuck on the s...

    A woman walking near Hauser Dam has been rescued after weather and slippery conditions caused her to get lost.  According to the Lewis and Clark County Sheriff's Office, the woman is safe and uninjured. Her identity has not yet been released. As of 10:30 Monday evening, authorities were taking the woman back to her vehicle.  At the same time, a group of 13 people lost their way in the Bob Marshall Wilderness. Lewis and Clark County Sheriffs say the group got stuck on the s...

  • Fishing access sites closed due to high water

    Fishing access sites closed due to high water

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 2:17 PM EDT2018-06-19 18:17:39 GMT
    CASCADE COUNTY - Montana Fish Wildlife & Parks has implemented closure of 2 fishing access sites due to flooding on the Sun River The Medicine River FAS and the Fort Shaw FAS are closed until further notice. FWP says they'll stay that way until the area can be cleaned up and deemed safe.
    CASCADE COUNTY - Montana Fish Wildlife & Parks has implemented closure of 2 fishing access sites due to flooding on the Sun River The Medicine River FAS and the Fort Shaw FAS are closed until further notice. FWP says they'll stay that way until the area can be cleaned up and deemed safe.
  • Governor requests aid from FEMA

    Governor requests aid from FEMA

    Monday, June 18 2018 5:51 PM EDT2018-06-18 21:51:14 GMT
    HELENA - Monday afternoon Governor Steve Bullock put in an official request to FEMA to provide additional resources back to Montana to help clean up and recover from the widespread spring flooding. If approved the money would be used to repair damaged roads, culverts, and bridges. Since April more than 20 counties, 8 cities, and 3 tribes have all declared emergencies. Then in May the Governor declared a statewide flooding emergency, however, state law requires that it expire in 20 ...
    HELENA - Monday afternoon Governor Steve Bullock put in an official request to FEMA to provide additional resources back to Montana to help clean up and recover from the widespread spring flooding. If approved the money would be used to repair damaged roads, culverts, and bridges. Since April more than 20 counties, 8 cities, and 3 tribes have all declared emergencies. Then in May the Governor declared a statewide flooding emergency, however, state law requires that it expire in 20 ...
  • Result are in! It's a wolf!

    Result are in! It's a wolf!

    Monday, June 18 2018 12:02 PM EDT2018-06-18 16:02:09 GMT
    Image Courtesy KXLOImage Courtesy KXLO
    Image Courtesy KXLOImage Courtesy KXLO
    The mysterious creature that captivated the nation after it was shot and killed near Denton in May has been identified. Montana Fish, Wildlife, & Parks says the animal is, in fact, a wolf. The carcass was sent to the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service forensic laboratory in Oregon. After comparing the DNA to thousands of samples from wolves, coyotes, and dogs and concluded it was a gray wolf from the northern Rocky Mountains.  FWP says the original pictures of ...
    The mysterious creature that captivated the nation after it was shot and killed near Denton in May has been identified. Montana Fish, Wildlife, & Parks says the animal is, in fact, a wolf. The carcass was sent to the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service forensic laboratory in Oregon. After comparing the DNA to thousands of samples from wolves, coyotes, and dogs and concluded it was a gray wolf from the northern Rocky Mountains.  FWP says the original pictures of ...
  • 57th Annual Montana 500 comes to Shelby

    57th Annual Montana 500 comes to Shelby

    Sunday, June 17 2018 8:13 PM EDT2018-06-18 00:13:27 GMT

    The 57th Annual Montana 500 Endurance Run for Model T's is starting up today as drivers from across the country gear up for the race in Shelby.  

    The 57th Annual Montana 500 Endurance Run for Model T's is starting up today as drivers from across the country gear up for the race in Shelby.