Benefis found Not Guilty in Back V. Benefis Trial - KULR8.com | News, Weather & Sports in Billings, Montana

Benefis found Not Guilty in Back V. Benefis Trial

It took jurors only 2 1/2 hours to come up with that unanimous verdict of not guilty for Benefis in the Back V. Benefis trial.


For the last 13 days, the jury heard testimony from doctors, expert witnesses, and even Roberts family.

A major role in this trial was athletic trainer Jessica Hansen.  The backs case was rooted in the fact she handled Roberts injury directly.


She said a lack of information from head coach Jeff Graham as well as the back family eventually lead her to say he was "ok concussion wise."

Shortly after the verdict was read, Benefis sent out this statement.

 

While Benefis Health System is pleased with the jury's finding that we are not responsible or liable for Robert Back's injuries, we continue to be deeply saddened by the tragic injuries Robert suffered. We wish Robert and his family nothing but the best for the future.


As for the Backs, we've been told this is the end of the road regarding the case. 

Steve Shapiro, attorney for the family gave us the following statement


"We did the very best we could... we did the best we could for our clients, and we respect the jury's decision."


Monday marked Day 1 in the case of Robert Back v. Benefis Health System. Over 270 people were originally called for jury duty, though that number dwindled down to 210 expected at the Montana Expo Park Monday morning for the start of jury selection. By 10 am, over half of those in attendance were deemed "statutorily disqualified," and even more were later dismissed for reasons ranging from medical concerns to travel plans and calving season. 

After lunch, the group moved back to the Cascade County Courthouse. The pool was narrowed down to the final 12 jurors and three alternates, who will eventually decide who will be held responsible for Robert Back's 2014 injury that left him permanently disabled. 

The trial is expected to last about three weeks. 

KFBB has been in contact with Back family attorney Steve Shapiro, and even had the opportunity to sit down with the Back family after Robert returned home from treatment.

For the first time in over a year, Benefis responded to our questions ahead of the case, releasing a statement that says:

"We are confident that when all the facts are presented at trial it will be clear that Benefis Health System should not be blamed for Robert Back's injuries.  Two medical doctors told Robert and his family that Robert was not to play football that week.  Two days before the game, Robert's doctor gave Robert and his family a note to give to Robert's football coaches making clear that Robert was not to play in the game Friday night. Robert and his family chose not to follow the doctors’ instructions.  

Everyone involved in this case at Benefis was deeply saddened by the tragic injuries Robert suffered, but it would be wrong to blame Benefis."

To see previous coverage over the years, click here

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Thousands Stolen from Stage Coach Motors

    Thousands Stolen from Stage Coach Motors

    Monday, September 17 2018 10:44 PM EDT2018-09-18 02:44:30 GMT
    Monday, September 17 2018 10:44 PM EDT2018-09-18 02:44:30 GMT
    Stage Coach Motors was broken into and robbed early Sunday morning in Ulm. Owner, Justen Wolf, explained that he discovered the robbery around 10:00 a.m. Sunday. He was missing thousands of dollars, a laptop and a van. Wolf has reported the incident to police and received a surveillance video. He believes that the white Chevrolet pickup truck involved was the same truck that crashed into Pita Pit later Sunday morning.  No word yet on if the incidents are related. To read mor...
    Stage Coach Motors was broken into and robbed early Sunday morning in Ulm. Owner, Justen Wolf, explained that he discovered the robbery around 10:00 a.m. Sunday. He was missing thousands of dollars, a laptop and a van. Wolf has reported the incident to police and received a surveillance video. He believes that the white Chevrolet pickup truck involved was the same truck that crashed into Pita Pit later Sunday morning.  No word yet on if the incidents are related. To read mor...
  • Bear spotted on MSU campus

    Bear spotted on MSU campus

    Monday, September 17 2018 1:17 PM EDT2018-09-17 17:17:28 GMT

    A bear was spotted on the Montana State University campus, prompting a warning from the university. 

    A bear was spotted on the Montana State University campus, prompting a warning from the university. 

  • Missoula officer on leave after gun found in school bathroom

    Missoula officer on leave after gun found in school bathroom

    Monday, September 17 2018 3:25 PM EDT2018-09-17 19:25:44 GMT

    A Missoula County school resource officer is on leave after allegedly leaving a duty weapon in a bathroom.

    A Missoula County school resource officer is on leave after allegedly leaving a duty weapon in a bathroom.

  • New Great Falls pet shop damaged during hit-and-run

    New Great Falls pet shop damaged during hit-and-run

    Monday, September 17 2018 11:33 PM EDT2018-09-18 03:33:59 GMT
    Monday, September 17 2018 11:33 PM EDT2018-09-18 03:33:59 GMT

    The Great Falls Police Department is investigating a hit and run on 3rd Street NW that damaged a building.

    The Great Falls Police Department is investigating a hit and run on 3rd Street NW that damaged a building.

  • Helena Public Schools Parents can track their kids on bus routes

    Helena Public Schools Parents can track their kids on bus routes

    Monday, September 17 2018 8:35 PM EDT2018-09-18 00:35:13 GMT
    Monday, September 17 2018 8:35 PM EDT2018-09-18 00:35:13 GMT
    Helena Public Schools say their transportation system is one of the safest in the country. On top of other safety features, they're getting ready to launch a system allowing parents to track their bus riders in real time. Starting in October, parents will be able to keep up with their students through an app. Kids will check on, and off the bus with an ID card. When they do, parents will receive a text letting them know exactly when their child stepped on, and off the bus. Throug...
    Helena Public Schools say their transportation system is one of the safest in the country. On top of other safety features, they're getting ready to launch a system allowing parents to track their bus riders in real time. Starting in October, parents will be able to keep up with their students through an app. Kids will check on, and off the bus with an ID card. When they do, parents will receive a text letting them know exactly when their child stepped on, and off the bus. Throug...
  • Crash on 10th Ave S. sends vehicle through Pita Pit wall

    Crash on 10th Ave S. sends vehicle through Pita Pit wall

    Sunday, September 16 2018 12:24 PM EDT2018-09-16 16:24:38 GMT
    Monday, September 17 2018 10:39 PM EDT2018-09-18 02:39:06 GMT

    Early Sunday morning, around 3 am, a vehicle hit another vehicle on 10th Avenue South. 

    Early Sunday morning, around 3 am, a vehicle hit another vehicle on 10th Avenue South. 

  • Woman falls 60 feet off cliff in Black Eagle

    Woman falls 60 feet off cliff in Black Eagle

    Monday, September 17 2018 6:28 PM EDT2018-09-17 22:28:55 GMT
    Monday, September 17 2018 6:28 PM EDT2018-09-17 22:28:55 GMT
    According to the Black Eagle Fire Chief, crews were called out around 10:30 pm Sunday night after reports that woman fell above the Rivers Edge Trail. When crews arrived, they had to carry the woman 200 yards to an ambulance were she was then taken to Benefis. We are don't know the extent of her injuries or why she was on the cliff in the first place. Cascade county also responded but Black Eagle Fire Department had the situation under control when they arrived
    According to the Black Eagle Fire Chief, crews were called out around 10:30 pm Sunday night after reports that woman fell above the Rivers Edge Trail. When crews arrived, they had to carry the woman 200 yards to an ambulance were she was then taken to Benefis. We are don't know the extent of her injuries or why she was on the cliff in the first place. Cascade county also responded but Black Eagle Fire Department had the situation under control when they arrived
  • Victims Identified in Fatal Crash Near Bozeman

    Victims Identified in Fatal Crash Near Bozeman

    Monday, October 7 2013 11:29 PM EDT2013-10-08 03:29:11 GMT
    Monday, October 7 2013 11:54 PM EDT2013-10-08 03:54:01 GMT
    54-year-old William Oldroyd of West Yellowstone and 24-year-old Jada Krusniak of Big Sky were reported dead at the scene when emergency officials arrived.  According to the Montana Highway Patrol, the
    We're just learning the names of the two people who died in a head-on collision west of Bozeman last night.
  • NewsMore>>

  • Missing 19-year-old found near Lolo Peak

    Missing 19-year-old found near Lolo Peak

    Monday, September 17 2018 2:15 PM EDT2018-09-17 18:15:41 GMT
    Monday, September 17 2018 2:15 PM EDT2018-09-17 18:15:41 GMT

    UPDATE: The 19-year-old was found at 8:30 PM and is okay, according to the Missoula County Sheriff's Office.

    UPDATE: The 19-year-old was found at 8:30 PM and is okay, according to the Missoula County Sheriff's Office.

  • Soldiers aiding Hurricane Florence relief

    Soldiers aiding Hurricane Florence relief

    Sunday, September 16 2018 8:29 PM EDT2018-09-17 00:29:14 GMT
    Sunday, September 16 2018 8:29 PM EDT2018-09-17 00:29:14 GMT
    HELENA- Hurricane Florence is leaving homes under water, people without power, and some waiting to be rescued, and that's why our Montana Army National Guard is sending crews to help. "Being able to help someone. I mean it's a good feeling actually getting out there and getting to do your job," said Shayde Crist, Crew Chief with Army National Guard.   19 soldiers left for Maryland early this morning, September 16th. Once they arrive on September 18th they'll be on call...
    HELENA- Hurricane Florence is leaving homes under water, people without power, and some waiting to be rescued, and that's why our Montana Army National Guard is sending crews to help. "Being able to help someone. I mean it's a good feeling actually getting out there and getting to do your job," said Shayde Crist, Crew Chief with Army National Guard.   19 soldiers left for Maryland early this morning, September 16th. Once they arrive on September 18th they'll be on call...
  • Two people arrested after stealing vehicle

    Two people arrested after stealing vehicle

    Sunday, September 16 2018 7:49 PM EDT2018-09-16 23:49:00 GMT
    Sunday, September 16 2018 7:49 PM EDT2018-09-16 23:49:00 GMT
    GREAT FALLS-  According to GFPD two people are now behind bars after officers caught them with a stolen vehicle.  It all started around 4:30 p.m. Saturday evening when an officer noticed a car at the intersection of 2nd Ave. S. and 14th St. S. The officer noticed a white 2018 Chevrolet Silverado that GFPD had been looking for.  When the officer put his sirens on, the driver who was a male and his passenger fled on 3rd Ave. S. at estimated speeds of 80 mph.  At t...
    GREAT FALLS-  According to GFPD two people are now behind bars after officers caught them with a stolen vehicle.  It all started around 4:30 p.m. Saturday evening when an officer noticed a car at the intersection of 2nd Ave. S. and 14th St. S. The officer noticed a white 2018 Chevrolet Silverado that GFPD had been looking for.  When the officer put his sirens on, the driver who was a male and his passenger fled on 3rd Ave. S. at estimated speeds of 80 mph.  At t...
  • First year for art vendors at Arts On Fire

    First year for art vendors at Arts On Fire

    Saturday, September 15 2018 7:51 PM EDT2018-09-15 23:51:46 GMT
    Saturday, September 15 2018 7:59 PM EDT2018-09-15 23:59:03 GMT

    GREAT FALLS- Arts On Fire is back at Paris Gibson and this year local vendors got into the action. We spoke with one potter who tells us why it’s important.  Jimmie Henry starts with just a lump of clay and adds different colors and elements to her own unique piece of pottery. She said this type of freedom is why she loves making art. But it’s not only one of a kind bowls. She also makes a variety of other items including bells.   "So, I like looking...

    GREAT FALLS- Arts On Fire is back at Paris Gibson and this year local vendors got into the action. We spoke with one potter who tells us why it’s important.  Jimmie Henry starts with just a lump of clay and adds different colors and elements to her own unique piece of pottery. She said this type of freedom is why she loves making art. But it’s not only one of a kind bowls. She also makes a variety of other items including bells.   "So, I like looking...

  • Under The Big Sky Buddy Walk

    Walking for awareness

    Walking for awareness

    Saturday, September 15 2018 6:40 PM EDT2018-09-15 22:40:44 GMT
    Saturday, September 15 2018 6:40 PM EDT2018-09-15 22:40:44 GMT
    GREAT FALLS- Down syndrome is still the most common chromosome disorder according to the Centers for Disease Control, and this morning, September 18th people from across our community gathered at the University of Providence raising awareness about the disorder. Under The Big Sky Buddy Walk is in its ninth year. This walk is a way to bring those with and without Down syndrome together. By understanding this disorder people are able to realize there's nothing different with those who ...
    GREAT FALLS- Down syndrome is still the most common chromosome disorder according to the Centers for Disease Control, and this morning, September 18th people from across our community gathered at the University of Providence raising awareness about the disorder. Under The Big Sky Buddy Walk is in its ninth year. This walk is a way to bring those with and without Down syndrome together. By understanding this disorder people are able to realize there's nothing different with those who ...
  • Domino's paves the way to better roads in Havre

    Domino's paves the way to better roads in Havre

    Thursday, September 13 2018 5:55 PM EDT2018-09-13 21:55:31 GMT
    Thursday, September 13 2018 5:55 PM EDT2018-09-13 21:55:31 GMT

    HAVRE - Domino's Pizza launched a nationwide social media campaign over the summer to help pave America's roads. Paving began Thursday morning around 9:30 along 12th Avenue between First and Fourth St. 

    HAVRE - Domino's Pizza launched a nationwide social media campaign over the summer to help pave America's roads. Paving began Thursday morning around 9:30 along 12th Avenue between First and Fourth St. 

  • Montana Treasure: Grace Home

    Montana Treasure: Grace Home

    Monday, September 10 2018 6:42 PM EDT2018-09-10 22:42:15 GMT
    Monday, September 10 2018 6:42 PM EDT2018-09-10 22:42:15 GMT
    When driving along 5th Avenue North, you might notice the Grace Home. It's a place that helps homeless veterans get back on their feet. "The Grace Home has given me a place where I can heal," resident Edward Aguasanta said. "Where I can actually transition from where I was in life as far as coming home from war." The Grace Home has been around for two years now, and looks to give veterans hope. "A lot of residents coming in have been homeless for awhil...
    When driving along 5th Avenue North, you might notice the Grace Home. It's a place that helps homeless veterans get back on their feet. "The Grace Home has given me a place where I can heal," resident Edward Aguasanta said. "Where I can actually transition from where I was in life as far as coming home from war." The Grace Home has been around for two years now, and looks to give veterans hope. "A lot of residents coming in have been homeless for awhil...
  • Alcohol listed as factor in Plentywood volleyball team bus crash

    Alcohol listed as factor in Plentywood volleyball team bus crash

    Sunday, September 9 2018 8:31 PM EDT2018-09-10 00:31:12 GMT
    Sunday, September 9 2018 8:32 PM EDT2018-09-10 00:32:35 GMT

    Sheridan County Undersheriff Scott Nelson says alcohol is a factor in a two-vehicle crash that injured several members of the Plentywood Girls Volleyball Team.

    Sheridan County Undersheriff Scott Nelson says alcohol is a factor in a two-vehicle crash that injured several members of the Plentywood Girls Volleyball Team.