55-year-old cold case murder solved in Wyoming - KULR8.com | News, Weather & Sports in Billings, Montana

55-year-old cold case murder solved in Wyoming

Posted: Updated:
THERMOPOLIS, Wyo. -

A 55-year-old cold case is solved in Thermopolis, thanks to the hard work of the murder victim’s granddaughter. The woman from Des Moines, Iowa helped identify the remains that were found in a foot locker in the Wyoming town in 1992. Shelley Statler wants to honor Joseph Mulvaney, who was killed in 1962.

Thermopolis is a small central Wyoming community, known for its cowboys, hot springs,  and dinosaur bones, i.e. fossils.

But the bones found in a trunk on this property in 1992 were human remains. John Lumley was the Hot Springs County sheriff then.  He says he talked to the man who left the trunk in a shed in 1986. His name was John Morris aka David Tanner.

Lumley said, “He affirmed that he brought the trunk from state to state and moved it here and left it here.”

Lumley said he went to Texas to interview Morris about the remains. He felt Morris was a suspect in the victim’s murder.  But, Morris claimed he didn’t know the trunk had bones in it, and without forensic evidence at the time, no charges were filed.

Wyoming’s crime lab used the victim’s skull to recreate an image of his face.

Then, 25 years after the bones were found, he got a call last month from Shelley Statler of Iowa.

 He recalled, “I spent an hour and a half on the phone with Shelley in my initial time with her..”

Statler had read a newspaper article about the box with the bones.  And, she had heard stories from her family. She found Wyoming’s crime lab recreation and made a collage comparing the image to her families’ pictures.  She found a strong resemblance, and so did Lumley.

So he and Sheriff’s Office Sgt. Jeremie Kraushaar asked Statler to get a DNA sample from her mother, Katherine.  She did, and Wyoming’s crime lab compared the DNA to the bone fragments Kraushaar sent to them.

Khaushaar says he got an answer in late October:

He recalled,  “He said this is the father of the DNA sample.”

Statler said she got the message on October 26th.  Her mother was the daughter of the murdered man whose remains were found in Thermopolis 25 years ago.  Statler confirmed her Grandfather’s name: Joseph Mulvaney. 

 Statler called to say her grandfather was a World War II veteran and had three young children when he died. She said she believes he was killed by his wife, her grandmother. She said her grandmother has passed.

She wants to bring her grandfather’s  remains back to Iowa, to give him a proper military funeral.

Lumley said, “Totally gratified that there’s closure for a family.”

The Thermopolis cold case was featured in an early 90’s episode of the television show “Unsolved Mysteries”. The Sheriff’s office received more than 600 calls. But the tip that solved the mystery came from a woman who never saw the show’s episode about her grandfather.

  • LocalMore>>

  • Montana dentists fear cuts' effect on vulnerable patients

    Montana dentists fear cuts' effect on vulnerable patients

    Sunday, December 17 2017 1:29 PM EST2017-12-17 18:29:55 GMT

    BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) - Montana dentists say they fear state budget cuts for adult dental care will hurt people with disabilities and elderly people most.  

    BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) - Montana dentists say they fear state budget cuts for adult dental care will hurt people with disabilities and elderly people most.  

  • Bull riding teen makes fast recovery

    Bull riding teen makes fast recovery

    Sunday, December 17 2017 12:29 AM EST2017-12-17 05:29:43 GMT
    Kenna HazenKenna Hazen

    With National Finals Rodeo week coming to an end, we wanted to check in with one teen bull rider who wants to tackle the world of professional bull riding with full speed. The last time we saw Kenna Hazen, she was in the hospital after a bull riding accident left her with severe injuries. Six months later we wondered how this tough teen is holding up. "Physically I'm working with my trainer, but shes out of town so she gave me a few things to do to work out...

    With National Finals Rodeo week coming to an end, we wanted to check in with one teen bull rider who wants to tackle the world of professional bull riding with full speed. The last time we saw Kenna Hazen, she was in the hospital after a bull riding accident left her with severe injuries. Six months later we wondered how this tough teen is holding up. "Physically I'm working with my trainer, but shes out of town so she gave me a few things to do to work out...

  • Wyoming conducts experiment to find out if lower speed limits reduce wildlife collisions

    Wyoming conducts experiment to find out if lower speed limits reduce wildlife collisions

    Friday, December 15 2017 11:52 PM EST2017-12-16 04:52:53 GMT
    Last winter, Wyoming’s Department of Transportation tried a new lower night-time speed limit on the Yellowstone Highway near Cody. Now the number of wildlife accidents are down on that road. A large herd of elk is a daily sight along highway 14/16/20 in Wapiti, west of Cody. Elk and deer spend time in hay fields near what locals call the North Fork, or the Yellowstone Highway. It is their winter range. In 2014, hunting and conservation organizations helped fund new billbo...
    Last winter, Wyoming’s Department of Transportation tried a new lower night-time speed limit on the Yellowstone Highway near Cody. Now the number of wildlife accidents are down on that road. A large herd of elk is a daily sight along highway 14/16/20 in Wapiti, west of Cody. Elk and deer spend time in hay fields near what locals call the North Fork, or the Yellowstone Highway. It is their winter range. In 2014, hunting and conservation organizations helped fund new billbo...
  • TrendingMore>>

  • Wyoming conducts experiment to find out if lower speed limits reduce wildlife collisions

    Wyoming conducts experiment to find out if lower speed limits reduce wildlife collisions

    Friday, December 15 2017 11:52 PM EST2017-12-16 04:52:53 GMT
    Last winter, Wyoming’s Department of Transportation tried a new lower night-time speed limit on the Yellowstone Highway near Cody. Now the number of wildlife accidents are down on that road. A large herd of elk is a daily sight along highway 14/16/20 in Wapiti, west of Cody. Elk and deer spend time in hay fields near what locals call the North Fork, or the Yellowstone Highway. It is their winter range. In 2014, hunting and conservation organizations helped fund new billbo...
    Last winter, Wyoming’s Department of Transportation tried a new lower night-time speed limit on the Yellowstone Highway near Cody. Now the number of wildlife accidents are down on that road. A large herd of elk is a daily sight along highway 14/16/20 in Wapiti, west of Cody. Elk and deer spend time in hay fields near what locals call the North Fork, or the Yellowstone Highway. It is their winter range. In 2014, hunting and conservation organizations helped fund new billbo...
  • FCC votes to repeal Obama-era 'net neutrality' rules

    FCC votes to repeal Obama-era 'net neutrality' rules

    Thursday, December 14 2017 1:34 PM EST2017-12-14 18:34:29 GMT

    The Federal Communications Commission has voted on party lines to undo sweeping Obama-era "net neutrality" rules that guaranteed equal access to internet. 

    The Federal Communications Commission has voted on party lines to undo sweeping Obama-era "net neutrality" rules that guaranteed equal access to internet. 

  • See a movie in a theater every day for a year for only $90? Costco offering bundle for movie lovers

    See a movie in a theater every day for a year for only $90? Costco offering bundle for movie lovers

    Wednesday, December 13 2017 9:42 PM EST2017-12-14 02:42:06 GMT

    If you're into watching movies in theaters and at home, Costco has a deal for you!

    If you're into watching movies in theaters and at home, Costco has a deal for you!

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Bull riding teen makes fast recovery

    Bull riding teen makes fast recovery

    Sunday, December 17 2017 12:29 AM EST2017-12-17 05:29:43 GMT
    Kenna HazenKenna Hazen

    With National Finals Rodeo week coming to an end, we wanted to check in with one teen bull rider who wants to tackle the world of professional bull riding with full speed. The last time we saw Kenna Hazen, she was in the hospital after a bull riding accident left her with severe injuries. Six months later we wondered how this tough teen is holding up. "Physically I'm working with my trainer, but shes out of town so she gave me a few things to do to work out...

    With National Finals Rodeo week coming to an end, we wanted to check in with one teen bull rider who wants to tackle the world of professional bull riding with full speed. The last time we saw Kenna Hazen, she was in the hospital after a bull riding accident left her with severe injuries. Six months later we wondered how this tough teen is holding up. "Physically I'm working with my trainer, but shes out of town so she gave me a few things to do to work out...

  • Doctor accused of spiking pregnant girlfriend's drink with abortion pill

    Doctor accused of spiking pregnant girlfriend's drink with abortion pill

    Friday, December 15 2017 2:22 AM EST2017-12-15 07:22:19 GMT

    ROCHESTER, N.Y. - A doctor is accused of spiking his girlfriend's drink with an abortion pill.  Brooke Fiske told News 8 WROC in Rochester that she and Sikander Imran had been dating on and off for three years when she learned she was pregnant.  Fiske says he didn't want to have the baby so Imran tried talking her into having an abortion, but it wasn't something she wanted.  According to WROC, Imran had recently moved from New York to 

    ROCHESTER, N.Y. - A doctor is accused of spiking his girlfriend's drink with an abortion pill.  Brooke Fiske told News 8 WROC in Rochester that she and Sikander Imran had been dating on and off for three years when she learned she was pregnant.  Fiske says he didn't want to have the baby so Imran tried talking her into having an abortion, but it wasn't something she wanted.  According to WROC, Imran had recently moved from New York to 

  • Law enforcement arrests 20 people in multi-state meth ring

    Law enforcement arrests 20 people in multi-state meth ring

    Wednesday, December 13 2017 8:46 PM EST2017-12-14 01:46:30 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - According to the U.S. Attorney for Eastern Washington, federal, state and local law enforcement conducted a large scale take-down targeting a criminal conspiracy distributing methamphetamine in Washington, Idaho and Montana on Wednesday. Hundreds of law enforcement officials including federal agents and state and local officers executed federal search warrants in Spokane, Moses Lake, Mattawa and in North Idaho.

    SPOKANE, Wash. - According to the U.S. Attorney for Eastern Washington, federal, state and local law enforcement conducted a large scale take-down targeting a criminal conspiracy distributing methamphetamine in Washington, Idaho and Montana on Wednesday. Hundreds of law enforcement officials including federal agents and state and local officers executed federal search warrants in Spokane, Moses Lake, Mattawa and in North Idaho.

  • Wyoming woman accused of throwing baby into ditch

    Wyoming woman accused of throwing baby into ditch

    Wednesday, December 13 2017 6:18 PM EST2017-12-13 23:18:23 GMT

    Wyoming authorities have charged a woman with aggravated child abuse after police say she threw her 2-month-old daughter into a ditch.

    Wyoming authorities have charged a woman with aggravated child abuse after police say she threw her 2-month-old daughter into a ditch.

  • Police investigate tie between Missoula bones and Michigan case

    Police investigate tie between Missoula bones and Michigan case

    Thursday, December 14 2017 6:50 PM EST2017-12-14 23:50:38 GMT

    MORENCI, MICHIGAN-- Police are investigating whether the remains of three children found in Missoula could possibly solve a years-long mystery in Michigan. According to reporters at 13abc in Michigan, state police there have confirmed that they're in contact with Missoula police to determine whether the bones are related to the disappearance of three boys, ages tk. Experts determined that the bones found in a box in a shed in Missoula belonged to three children, ages tk, and se...

    MORENCI, MICHIGAN-- Police are investigating whether the remains of three children found in Missoula could possibly solve a years-long mystery in Michigan. According to reporters at 13abc in Michigan, state police there have confirmed that they're in contact with Missoula police to determine whether the bones are related to the disappearance of three boys, ages tk. Experts determined that the bones found in a box in a shed in Missoula belonged to three children, ages tk, and se...

  • See a movie in a theater every day for a year for only $90? Costco offering bundle for movie lovers

    See a movie in a theater every day for a year for only $90? Costco offering bundle for movie lovers

    Wednesday, December 13 2017 9:42 PM EST2017-12-14 02:42:06 GMT

    If you're into watching movies in theaters and at home, Costco has a deal for you!

    If you're into watching movies in theaters and at home, Costco has a deal for you!

  • Wyoming conducts experiment to find out if lower speed limits reduce wildlife collisions

    Wyoming conducts experiment to find out if lower speed limits reduce wildlife collisions

    Friday, December 15 2017 11:52 PM EST2017-12-16 04:52:53 GMT
    Last winter, Wyoming’s Department of Transportation tried a new lower night-time speed limit on the Yellowstone Highway near Cody. Now the number of wildlife accidents are down on that road. A large herd of elk is a daily sight along highway 14/16/20 in Wapiti, west of Cody. Elk and deer spend time in hay fields near what locals call the North Fork, or the Yellowstone Highway. It is their winter range. In 2014, hunting and conservation organizations helped fund new billbo...
    Last winter, Wyoming’s Department of Transportation tried a new lower night-time speed limit on the Yellowstone Highway near Cody. Now the number of wildlife accidents are down on that road. A large herd of elk is a daily sight along highway 14/16/20 in Wapiti, west of Cody. Elk and deer spend time in hay fields near what locals call the North Fork, or the Yellowstone Highway. It is their winter range. In 2014, hunting and conservation organizations helped fund new billbo...
  • Man ejected after rolling car, hit and killed by passing motorist

    Man ejected after rolling car, hit and killed by passing motorist

    Wednesday, December 13 2017 12:50 PM EST2017-12-13 17:50:52 GMT

    One man is dead after he was ejected in a rollover crash and was then hit by a passing vehicle.

    One man is dead after he was ejected in a rollover crash and was then hit by a passing vehicle.