No monkeying around: Court weighs if animal owns its selfies - KULR8.com | Montana's News Leader | Billings, MT

No monkeying around: Court weighs if animal owns its selfies

Posted: Updated:

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) - A curious monkey with a toothy grin and a knack for pressing a camera button was back in the spotlight as a federal appeals court on Wednesday questioned lawyers fighting about an animal's ability to hold a copyright to selfie photos.

Naruto is a free-living crested macaque who snapped the pictures with an unattended camera in Sulawesi, Indonesia, in 2011. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals said Naruto was accustomed to cameras and took the selfies when he saw himself in the reflection of the lens.

PETA sued British nature photographer David Slater, whose camera the monkey used, and a San Francisco-based self-publishing company Blurb, which put out a book called "Wildlife Personalities" that includes the photos.

The animal rights organization wants to administer all proceeds from the photos to benefit the monkey. Slater's company holds the British copyright for the photos, and he says it should be honored worldwide.

A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco appeared puzzled by PETA's role in the case, asking the group's attorney why it should be allowed to represent the monkey's interests.

Attorney David Schwarz said the question had not been raised in court previously, and he urged the panel to define authorship for copyright purposes.

The judges did not issue a ruling.

Angela Dunning, attorney for Blurb, said the self-publishing company was confident it would prevail but wondered at the possibility if it did not.

"Where does it end? If a monkey can sue for copyright infringement, what else can a monkey do?" she said.

Dunning said Naruto can't hold copyright in part because he cannot grant permission to others to use his photos and can't benefit financially from the pictures. The monkey, she said, is "blissfully unaware" of what's happening in court.

A federal judge ruled against the monkey last year, saying there was no indication that Congress intended to extend copyright protection to animals.

PETA's general counsel Jeff Kerr said after the hearing that the group has plans to use money from the photos to protect monkey habitats and help people study the species.

"PETA is clearly representing Naruto's best interests," he said.

(Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

  • TrendingMore>>

  • Wyoming's ferret, wolf reintroductions inspire national park in Argentina

    Wyoming's ferret, wolf reintroductions inspire national park in Argentina

    Friday, September 22 2017 2:26 PM EDT2017-09-22 18:26:01 GMT

    Wyoming’s black-footed ferrets and Yellowstone’s wolves may have inspired the return of wildlife to a new national park in Argentina. Organizers are calling it the largest reintroduction program in the Americas.

    Wyoming’s black-footed ferrets and Yellowstone’s wolves may have inspired the return of wildlife to a new national park in Argentina. Organizers are calling it the largest reintroduction program in the Americas.

  • Colorado cops search for poop-and-run jogger

    Colorado cops search for poop-and-run jogger

    Wednesday, September 20 2017 7:18 PM EDT2017-09-20 23:18:44 GMT

    Police in Colorado are looking for a jogger they say is repeatedly interrupting her runs to defecate in public in one neighborhood.

    Police in Colorado are looking for a jogger they say is repeatedly interrupting her runs to defecate in public in one neighborhood.

  • Kohl's to start accepting Amazon returns at some stores

    Kohl's to start accepting Amazon returns at some stores

    Tuesday, September 19 2017 6:32 PM EDT2017-09-19 22:32:13 GMT

    Kohl's, which is opening some in-store Amazon shops, says it will start accepting returns for the online retailer at some of its stores in Los Angeles and Chicago starting next month.

    Kohl's, which is opening some in-store Amazon shops, says it will start accepting returns for the online retailer at some of its stores in Los Angeles and Chicago starting next month.

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Verizon will not terminate Montana contracts

    Verizon will not terminate Montana contracts

    Friday, September 22 2017 11:41 AM EDT2017-09-22 15:41:48 GMT

    U.S. Senator Jon Tester has successfully defended Montanans from Verizon’s attempt to terminate contracts. Verizon responded to Tester’s demands Friday. Tester received assurances from Verizon that no Montanans will be involuntarily removed from their contract.

    U.S. Senator Jon Tester has successfully defended Montanans from Verizon’s attempt to terminate contracts. Verizon responded to Tester’s demands Friday. Tester received assurances from Verizon that no Montanans will be involuntarily removed from their contract.

  • Man dies after being beaten in Lame Deer

    Man dies after being beaten in Lame Deer

    Friday, September 22 2017 11:27 AM EDT2017-09-22 15:27:30 GMT

    The BIA and FBI are investigating an incident that occurred on September 17th in Lame Deer that left Ozzy Lee Wilson hospitalized. Friday morning the FBI confirmed that Wilson has died as a result of those injuries. 

    The BIA and FBI are investigating an incident that occurred on September 17th in Lame Deer that left Ozzy Lee Wilson hospitalized. Friday morning the FBI confirmed that Wilson has died as a result of those injuries. 

  • UPDATE: Daisy Dukes bouncer sent to hospital after stabbing, one man arrested

    UPDATE: Daisy Dukes bouncer sent to hospital after stabbing, one man arrested

    Friday, September 22 2017 2:14 PM EDT2017-09-22 18:14:38 GMT

    Billings Police say a Daisy Dukes security guard is recovering in the hospital after being stabbed in the leg. 

    Billings Police say a Daisy Dukes security guard is recovering in the hospital after being stabbed in the leg. 

  • Deputy rescues man from overturned semi

    Deputy rescues man from overturned semi

    Friday, September 22 2017 2:58 PM EDT2017-09-22 18:58:09 GMT

    A Park County Deputy is being hailed as a hero on Facebook after coming to the rescue of a man trapped inside the cab of his rolled over semi-truck Friday morning. 

    A Park County Deputy is being hailed as a hero on Facebook after coming to the rescue of a man trapped inside the cab of his rolled over semi-truck Friday morning. 

  • Mountain lion spotted in Laurel

    Mountain lion spotted in Laurel

    Wednesday, September 20 2017 12:53 PM EDT2017-09-20 16:53:28 GMT

    A mountain lion has been spotted in Laurel multiple times over the past week. 

    A mountain lion has been spotted in Laurel multiple times over the past week. 

  • Ron Parker, 9/11 first responder, talks about his experience

    Ron Parker, 9/11 first responder, talks about his experience

    Saturday, September 23 2017 12:41 AM EDT2017-09-23 04:41:49 GMT
    Sixteen years ago, the World Trade Center was attacked on September eleventh. Saturday, Ron Parker, a first responder in New York city at the time of the attack, will speak at the Angel Horse Fundraiser. Born and raised in Brooklyn, Ron Parker said he only grew up 7 miles from the World Trade Center, affectionately called the twin towers.  "I was there from September 11th, that morning, until January 6th 2002.," Parker said."I lost 45 of my friends there. My day...
    Sixteen years ago, the World Trade Center was attacked on September eleventh. Saturday, Ron Parker, a first responder in New York city at the time of the attack, will speak at the Angel Horse Fundraiser. Born and raised in Brooklyn, Ron Parker said he only grew up 7 miles from the World Trade Center, affectionately called the twin towers.  "I was there from September 11th, that morning, until January 6th 2002.," Parker said."I lost 45 of my friends there. My day...
  • Flood-Damaged Vehicle Scam Warning

    Flood-Damaged Vehicle Scam Warning

    Thursday, September 21 2017 7:05 PM EDT2017-09-21 23:05:25 GMT

    Tips on how to not fall victim to scammers who take flood-damaged vehicles and make them look like new.

    Tips on how to not fall victim to scammers who take flood-damaged vehicles and make them look like new.

  • Person responsible for flag found in dumpster remains unknown

    Person responsible for flag found in dumpster remains unknown

    Friday, September 22 2017 10:27 PM EDT2017-09-23 02:27:02 GMT

    The Billings Army Reserve tells us they are unable to determine who is responsible for throwing an American flag in their dumpster because there are more people who have access to those dumpsters than just their employees.

    The Billings Army Reserve tells us they are unable to determine who is responsible for throwing an American flag in their dumpster because there are more people who have access to those dumpsters than just their employees.