Officials Sift Through Wreckage

Tools

Courtesy photo by Martha Guidoni

By KULR Staff & The Associated Press

BILLINGS - Shredded metal, pieces of propeller and a seat cushion are among the few discernible items at the scene of a single-engine plane crash that killed 14 people Sunday in Butte.

Federal officials on Tuesday gave a few reporters and photographers the first close look at Sunday's crash site. Seven children were among those killed when the Pilatus PC-12 small plane crashed into a cemetery near the Butte airport.

Working among rows of granite headstones cordoned off by yellow police tape, investigators removed the last of the victims' luggage as they combed through the wreckage.

Smaller pieces of debris were picked up, logged and then placed in plastic bags. Larger pieces, including the wings and a piece of the plane's tail, were confined to an area of a few hundred square feet.


Investigators said there are no survivors after a single engine plane crashed in Butte Sunday afternoon.

A spokesman for the FAA said about 14 people were on board, many of those passengers were children between the ages of 4 and 9. He said he believes they were on a ski trip. The turboprop plane is a "Pilatus PC-12" registered to a company in Enterprise, Oregon. A website that tracks aircraft reports the plane originally took off from San Diego Saturday evening and stopped in Redlands and Vacaville before taking off from Oroville, CA at about 11:00 a.m. Sunday.

The plane was scheduled to land in Bozeman, but FAA officials said the pilot re-routed for unknown reasons and crashed about 500 feet short of the runway in Butte.

The plane crashed into the Holy Cross Cemetery on the south side of Butte. Witnesses said they knew something was wrong shortly before the plane came up short of the runway.

Investigators will work through the night examining the crash site for any clues that will help them determine why the plane went down. Authorities said the process of recovering the bodies will not happen until Monday. Other counties are offering their assistance to help in the difficult task.

"Missoula county has called in to offer their assistance in the recovery that will start Monday," said Kristi Dunks with the NTSB.

"The coroner's office is in charge, they'll be bringing in extra resources to aid in the recovery which is under the direction of the local coroner's office," said Sheriff John Walsh of Butte-Silver Bow County.

The NTSB said it is still collecting information on the flight and those on board.

Montana Senator Max Baucus and Senator John Tester released statements after the accident offering condolences and prayers to the families affected by the crash.

"I'm deeply saddened to hear of this tragedy. My thoughts and prayers are with the families and friends of the victims, and with the people of Butte. The situation is in the very capable hands of Montana's emergency workers, they are true professionals and my thoughts are with them, as well. This is a very sad day for Montana." Said Senator Baucus.

"I ask all Americans to keep the victims, their families and friends, and emergency crews on scene in their thoughts and prayers as this tragic news unfolds. This is a heart-wrenching chapter in Montana's history. My thanks to all professionals responding to this crash. They have a tough job ahead. Working together, we now begin the long healing process." Said Senator Tester.

The victims of a Montana plane crash were three California families traveling to the Yellowstone Club for a skiing vacation.

Bud Feldkamp, who leased the airplane that crashed Sunday in Butte, said he and his wife lost two daughters and their families, while club member Bob Ching and his wife lost a son and his family.

Bud Feldkamp said the victims included his sisters Amy Jacobson of St. Helena, Calif., and Vanessa Pullen of Lodi, Calif. Jacobson's husband, Erin, and their children Taylor, 4; Ava, 3; Jude, 1, also died in the crash as did Pullen's husband, Michael, and their children Sydney, 9, and Christopher, 7.

Ching's son, Brent, of Durham, Calif., was killed in the crash along with his wife, Kristen and their children, Heyley, 5 and Caleb, 4.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Mike said on Thursday, Mar 26 at 6:17 PM

It's always hard to figure out what witnesses say they saw. There have been several accidents where the flight of the plane was very erratic right up to where they crashed. They involved the aircraft trim system stuck in the "up" position. The autopilot masks this condition until the pilot turns it off to land. All of a sudden the plane wants to climb straight up then stall. Unless the pilot had practiced recovering from that event, it is unlikely he would recover from a low altitude.

Pilot Rick said on Wednesday, Mar 25 at 5:59 PM

The airplane involved was equipped with 8 passenger seats and 2 crew seats. So long as the gross weight was not exceeded it is possible to seat 2 small children in a single seat or a child on an adults lap. Overweight does not make sense, it would have burned hundreds of pounds of fuel since departure. No ice was reported in the area and the aircraft is certified for known ice conditions. The diversion from the intended destination is a key. Beginning to sound like someone/pilot? became ill.

Kathryn Hosko said on Tuesday, Mar 24 at 9:04 PM

I just cannot seem to get the faces of the families that perished out of my mind. I cannot imagine what it would be like to loose any family member in a crash let alone 2 daughters, their husbands, 5 grandchildren and their friends. These people left behind need our prayers more than ever. May God grant them the peace they need to survive.

mapondude said on Tuesday, Mar 24 at 3:00 PM

weight at the time of crash could not be an issue even when there were a few too many people on the plane. The weight of the seven small children easily would have allowed the plane to fly. If weight was an issue the plane would have crashed at take off when it had all the fuel weight. The plane weighed several hundred pounds or even a thousand pounds less at the time of the crash then at take off. Weather conditions do not appear to be condusive for much icing either. Things do not add up.

Perk11350@aol.com said on Tuesday, Mar 24 at 1:43 AM

The aircraft type is important. The news report I heard listed visibility at 10-miles. The aerial photo of the area shows a crash site that is about midway along the length of the runway - to the south - on what would have been the downwind leg of a standard approach. I'e used PC-12 aircraft numerous times for medical evacuation - marvelously reliable aircraft by all accounts. Yes - the facts are conflicting at this point (for me anyway)

snorida said on Monday, Mar 23 at 11:57 PM

also interesting the lack of control one has when your wings are iced over and visibility is low...

Anonymous said on Monday, Mar 23 at 11:11 AM

Interesting that this plane crashed into Holy Cross Cemetary. The cemetary is off to the side of the runway, not at the end of the runway. Wonder why it's being reported that the plane crashed 'short' of the runway.

Concerned said on Monday, Mar 23 at 10:23 AM

People at work thought that the weight distribution might have been a factor. If there were small children on the flight they might have been moving around when they should have stayed in their seat. But a flight from California is a very long way. My prayers go out to those famlies. Such a tragic story.

prophecy said on Monday, Mar 23 at 4:41 AM

Human error, whether related or destiny, who can tell? GodYesOrNo.com

Ruedi said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 8:57 PM

A Pilatus PC-12 Aircraft can carry max 9 passanger and two pilots (a total of max 11 people.

K said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 8:54 PM

I would like to express my deepest sympathy to the families of these precious people. We lost two family members in a plane crash just two months ago. It was also a Pilatus (crashed l mile from the runway.) The pain is almost unbearable we will pray for you.

JOLYNN TRAYNOR said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 8:08 PM

PLANES AND PHOTOS CAN BE REPLACED, PEOPLE CAN NOT BE AND FAMILYS HAVE BEEN HURT AND CRUSH. THAT CAN NEVER BE HEALED. COME ON PEOPLE GET IT TOGETHER AND START CARING ABOUT THE LIFES TAKEN NOT A OBJECT THAT CAN BE FIXED AND FLY AGAIN. U ALSO HAE TO THINK THE PEOPLE THAT HAVE THERE FAMILYS BURIED IN THERE THAT THE STONES HAVE BEEN CRUSHED NEVER CAN BE REPLACED. AGAIN I SEND THE PRAYS TO THE FAMILY AND FRIENDS.

Anonymous said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 7:23 PM

I have noticed they always use a picture of the same plane when one crashes--no matter what size of plane crashed. It's just something to catch someone's eye people. Let's be real about what is REALLY important here.

Anonymous said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 7:21 PM

You really care what plane stock photo was used. Bet you wouldn't give a damn if it was your child that was killed.

jcbigsky said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 7:17 PM

This is a terrible tragedy. A source told me he called the Yellowstone Jet Center at Gallatin Field and there were two women waiting for the plane to land. It may have been connected to the Yellowstone Club at Big Sky. Our prayers go out to the families.

Old Timer said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 7:14 PM

IT WAS A PICTURE OF A PLANE!!! I use to work in news and you have to use what you have. Beats a big blank spot... and am sure their template calls for one. Is that all you can do is b**ch about the picture? What about the kids that were killed... get a life! They got the "breaking" news out about the crash..gzz

Kenny said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 6:55 PM

I can't believe that all you people seem to care about is what type of plane it was. You all need to take a good, hard look at yourself and ask were your humanity went because maybe 17 people died in this accident.

FAIRTV said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 6:32 PM

The Cessna pictured is NOT involved.

agree said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 6:13 PM

Completely agree with BruceAir! Remove the cessna 182 picture!

Jerry said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 5:57 PM

It was a Pilatus PC-12, and it was only designed to carry nine passengers. Check the wikipedia article.

Paul B. Walker, Jr. said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 5:54 PM

Sseeplane, working in the media (on the radio side).. I totally agree with you.. I wish TELEVISION NEWS CREWS weren't so sloppy and in a rush just to get a story done!

sseeplane said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 5:37 PM

Amen, BruceAir, unfortunately, the media has never let the facts get in the way of a good story.

Amanda said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 5:26 PM

If you review the registration for the aircraft tail number, the plane only seats 12. Where is the 17 dead number coming from? How can you report fatalities when families are involved without decent facts?

BruceAir said on Sunday, Mar 22 at 5:23 PM

The stock photo used to illustrate your initial story shows a Cessna 182 Skylane, which has a total of four seats. It would be better not to include an illustration until you confirm what type of aircraft was involved; using a generic illustration just adds to the confusion typical in the aftermath of an accident such as this.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

KULR-8 News, Sports, Weather and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

Your Weather Authority

Icon
Current Temp 45.0 °F
Partly Cloudy
Wind : West at
13.8 mph
Humidity : 77 %
Pressure : 29.92 in
More Weather

Sky Cam

More Weather

AP Video

On Demand

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Cast Your Vote

Do you agree with President Obama's decision to end combat operations in Iraq?

  • Yes
  • No

Links We Like